Louisiana's old-school math
Meta, SpaceX and Hyundai came largely on cash, tax breaks and geography. Researchers say there's a more efficient and effective model.
Louisiana landed Meta, SpaceX and Hyundai the old-fashioned way—by writing enormous checks, mostly in the form of tax breaks. The research says there's a better way to do economic development.
Why it matters: Louisiana sells itself as a MAGA, pro-business, free-market, limited-government state, yet its biggest wins run heavy on corporate welfare and subsidized taxpayer-backed breaks—and the research says that's an expensive way to buy a job.
Research says: Economists and economic developers increasingly say the most efficient and effective way to land jobs is to have deals prioritize workforce training, higher education partnerships and community investments—rather than massive tax breaks and other corporate welfare subsidies. This isn't new, and the evidence goes back years.
- The W.E. Upjohn Institute, a nonpolitical nonprofit that researches economic policy, says states are buying jobs the expensive way. States and localities spend about $95 billion a year on incentives—roughly 85% of it cash or tax credits. Untargeted cash incentives, the report says, return $1.75 in economic benefits but only 17 cents to state and local budgets per $1.
- Louisiana's legislative auditor supports the view that buying jobs offers a low ROI, saying in a 2020 audit that Quality Jobs, the state's payroll rebate, returned 10 cents in state revenue per $1 at best. LED called the auditor's model flawed.
- Strategic higher education partnerships are increasingly deal bedrocks. A 2019 corporate survey, cited in a McKinsey analysis, ranked labor availability ahead of tax exemptions and incentives when companies pick sites. Companies shop for talent before tax breaks. Nationally, 97% of state higher education executives now rank economic development as their top priority, the highest level since their association began tracking.
- Louisiana has embraced these partnerships before. When Stephen Moret ran LED under the Gov. Bobby Jindal administration, IBM's 800-job Baton Rouge center came with $14 million over 10 years for computer science, with at least 65% for LSU, which planned to double its faculty and triple its graduates.
SpaceX: The Vermilion Parish deal is almost entirely tax relief—$27.5 billion in potential value on a $100 billion investment, or about $9 million per direct job.
- A property tax break through a PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes) accounts for $23.9 billion, and a sales tax rebate adds $3.7 billion, per the letter of intent.
- Job training gets $2.8 million, about 0.01% of the package.
Meta: LED never put an all-in price tag on the Richland Parish data center, but the breaks on the public record are almost all tax relief.
- A 2024 state law exempts Meta's equipment from sales tax for 20 years, worth at least $3.3 billion according to a Sherwood News analysis done when the project was still $10 billion.
- Under a 30-year PILOT, Meta's buildings pay as little as 20% of the normal property tax, and its servers pay nothing, according to the term sheet.
- Meta says it's paying more than $1 billion for roads and water itself, the one piece that runs against type.
Hyundai: The Ascension Parish mill comes closest to the research, but the package, reported at about $2.6 billion on a $5.8 billion investment, is still mostly tax relief.
- About a fifth of the original $2.4 billion in LED's December 2024 letter goes to site work, land and training. The PILOT alone is half.
- A $30 million training center at River Parishes Community College and a research agreement with LSU give it an education tie.
Taxpayer protections: Louisiana's deals carry strings, but how tight they are depends on the company, and the state has loosened them before.
- Meta and Hyundai tie their incentives to jobs and investment, and Meta's property tax break shrinks if it misses its job targets.
- SpaceX's letter of intent lists no clawback for missed targets, though some benefits depend on jobs and wages.
- IBM missed its 800-job commitment in 2017 with 572 jobs, and the Edwards administration gave it two more years and a $10,000-per-job penalty.
In contrast: Virginia won Amazon's HQ2 by selling talent, higher education partnerships and the region's diverse quality of life.
- Moret, who ran point on Amazon's recruitment, said a bid built on incentives alone would have lost. The key was Virginia putting $1.1 billion into a tech talent program at its universities, against $573 million in grants paid to Amazon only as the jobs appear.
- New York offered about $3 billion, and Maryland reportedly put $8.5 billion on the table.
- Moret started FastStart, Louisiana's workforce training program, at LED and adapted it for Virginia. It's the same program that gets $2.8 million in the SpaceX deal.
The bottom line: Cash will always be part of the game, and Louisiana scored big wins by landing SpaceX, Meta and Hyundai. Less certain is whether the Landry administration cut a good deal for taxpayers and the state's future economy.