> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.redeyebr.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Is Lane Kiffin a great coach?
- URL: https://www.redeyebr.com/is-lane-kiffin-a-great-coach/
- Published: 2026-11-13T03:14:29.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-13T03:14:29.000Z
- Description: In his new book, Jared Diamond offers a few keys for coaching to win. Kiffin is not measuring up in one of the criteria, but its early in the game.
- Author: Mukul Verma
- Tags: News, Analysis

Is there an objective way to spot an exceptionally good coach, or an exceptionally bad one? Jared Diamond poses that question in his new book,[ *Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings: (When) Do Leaders Matter?*](https://books.google.com/books/about/Profits%5FProphets%5FCoaches%5Fand%5FKings.html?id=iVbFEQAAQBAJ&ref=redeyebr.com)

**Why it matters:** LSU is 6-3, and 3-3 in the SEC, under first-year coach Lane Kiffin. The losses came to Ole Miss, Kentucky and Alabama, and fans are already grading him.

**Driving the news:** Diamond, the UCLA geography professor emeritus best known for *Guns, Germs, and Steel*, devotes a section of his new book to coaches. Sports is a good lab for studying leaders, he argues, because the score is posted every week.

**What Diamond says:**

- **The gold standard:** Diamond singles out John Wooden, who won 10 NCAA titles at UCLA, seven of them in a row. He ranks Wooden as possibly the greatest American sports coach of modern times.
- By wins alone, Nick Saban belongs in that conversation too, with seven national titles, including LSU's in 2003.
- **Most coaching is fuzzy.** Results hinge on talent, money, facilities and timing. Research Diamond cites finds coaches explain only about 21% to 31% of the differences in team success.
- **Firing is often the wrong fix.** A team that fires a losing coach usually improves the next year, but so does a team that keeps one. That's regression to the mean, not the new coach.
- **And it's expensive.** Schools keep paying a fired coach through the end of his contract. LSU paid $54 million to buy out Brian Kelly's contract and $91 million to hire Kiffin for seven years.
- **What separates coaches:** Diamond expected coaches to differ in how often they run or pass. They don't; most settle on the same mix. Studies find they differ a lot in something else: how well they train players not to fumble or draw penalties, a key to winning games.

**By the numbers:** *RedEye* tested Diamond's idea against all 52 SEC conference games played this season through Nov. 7.

- **Turnovers tracked wins.** In 39 games, one team had the better turnover margin. That team won 33, about 85%.
- When the gap was two or more turnovers, the team with the better margin won 23 of 26.
- **Penalties didn't.** Winners had fewer penalty yards in 26 games and more in 24, with two ties. That's a coin flip.
- Even lopsided flag counts didn't decide games. When one team had at least 40 more penalty yards, the cleaner team won only 4 of 10.

**Then vs. now:** Kiffin's LSU team takes fewer penalties than his last Ole Miss squad but gives the ball away more often.

**Zoom in:** Interceptions are the main leak. Nine of LSU's 13 giveaways were picks; four were lost fumbles.

- In SEC play, LSU has the second-fewest penalty yards per game, 39.8\. Yet it has won the turnover battle in only one of six league games, the 35-6 win over Texas A&M.
- In its three losses, LSU was even in turnovers against Ole Miss and −2 against both Kentucky and Alabama.
- Ole Miss's margin last year was still negative, 11th in the SEC. It won anyway by rarely giving the ball away.

**Yes, but:** The sample size is small. Each SEC team has played only six or seven league games this season. 

**Two-part test:** Diamond names fumbles and penalties. In the SEC, penalty yards barely predicted winners, and that's the part LSU is passing.

**The bottom line:** Good coaches cut mistakes, and in the SEC the mistake that costs games is the turnover. Kiffin's LSU has cleaned up its flags; ball security is the grade that's still out.

Diamond's advice is to be patient. A coach who wins 70% of his games is no Wooden, he says, but ["be satisfied"](https://thoughteconomics.com/jared-diamond/?ref=redeyebr.com) and don't buy him out. LSU is at 67%.

## Sign up for RedEye

Journalism to kickstart Baton Rouge

Subscribe 

Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup. 

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.